Read this: 11 of the best double-albums in rock and metal
Of course, they did agree to work together on the record, with Halsey opening up about the songwriting process and how Trent and Atticus' vision eventually came through.
"Trent said something to me that I'll never forget for the rest of my life, where he was like, 'Hey, the record is great how it is,'" the singer says. "He was like, 'So you could not do this with us and put it out.' He's like, 'Or, the way a lot of modern music is right now is it informs the listener not to pay attention. It says, this song is safe. You can put it on a playlist. You can listen to it in a car. You can play it on a party, and it's not going to fuck up the vibe. It blends in with everything else. It's a mood. It's chill. But it informs you not to pay attention.'
"He was like, 'Your songs, I think, deserve better than that, and I think that they should make people pay attention to what you're saying.' He said, 'So I'm going to make some really weird choices.' And I was like, 'Please make weird choices. Make the weirdest choices!'
"So he sent back two songs at first, him and Atticus, and they told me later on, they were like, 'There's no way she's going…' And Trent and Atticus told me later, they were like, 'As soon as you were like, 'These are amazing,' they were like, 'Alright, it's go time. She wants to play.' You know what I mean?"
Halsey continues: "They wanted to know if I was willing to take the risk, and I was. I was willing to take the risk, and I also felt like I had earned it, at that point, to be able to, where it's like, I feel like every artist on their fourth, fifth, whatever album, especially pop artists, are always like, 'I really want to do something experimental. I really want to do something experimental.'"
The full interview will air on Apple Music 1 at 5pm on August 30.
In the meantime, listen to If I Can't Have Love, I Want Power below now: